Can I eat well without wrecking the planet?
That’s the question Somini Sengupta poses at the beginning of this article, and she goes on to answer it with five simple ideas explored in rich, sensory detail.
As part of our Mentor Text series, we’ve been trying something new: inviting Times journalists across sections to annotate their own articles to help demystify the research, reporting and writing process. Ms. Sengupta’s piece is our latest, but you can also read one about a tiny tyrannosaur by a science reporter, and one about college football by a sports reporter.
Below, paragraphs from the original piece are in bold, reproduced exactly as Ms. Sengupta wrote them, with the images and hyperlinks intact. Following each bolded section are her comments about how she structured the story, what she does to help the reader experience a place and its cuisine, how she plays with the sounds of words, and why she makes sure to always include a “why-it-matters” paragraph.
You can read more of Ms. Sengupta’s reporting here, and you can also read the original article in Spanish.
“These Five Cuisines Are Easier on the Planet,” by Somini Sengupta
Can I eat well without wrecking the planet? As a climate reporter and personal chef to a growing, ravenous child, I think about this question a lot. Is there a cuisine somewhere in the world that is healthy both for us and for the planet we live on? And if one exists, would we even want to eat it?
Somini Sengupta: I don’t often use the first-person voice in my reported stories. But in this case, I wanted to tell the reader why this issue matters to me personally. So the lead of the story, the first paragraph, has the rare “I” in it.
Turns out, there is no magic cuisine to save our species. There are, however, many ways to eat sustainably. They’re built into many traditional cuisines around the world, and we can learn from them.
If you raise a question in the lead, you’ve got to answer that question pretty quickly, but without giving away the rest of the story. You want your readers to keep reading, after all.
In any case, we don’t have much choice. To avert the most severe effects of climate change, scientists say, we have to very quickly transform the way we eat. Food production accounts for somewhere between 21 and 26 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions, depending on how you slice the data; food waste accounts for an additional 8 percent, considering that worldwide, we waste a third of the food we produce. Also, with climate change turbocharging droughts and storms, there are new risks to food security for the 800 million people worldwide who don’t have enough to eat.
This is what I call the why-it-matters paragraph. Every story needs this. It’s where I, the reporter, step back and give you, the reader, three quick factoids about why it’s important to think about your food choices if you’re concerned about the future of humanity — a.k.a. climate change.
Eating well doesn’t have to mean eating weirdly, or depriving ourselves, or even breaking the bank. Here are five simple ideas to guide you, whether you’re eating out or cooking at home.
I could have structured this story in several ways, but listing these (pardon the pun) bite-size lessons seemed like a good format.
Vietnam: Less meat, but not meatless
I wrote most of these section heads, but my editor, Douglas Alteen, who is brilliant at headlines, made them better.
Pho, the hearty Vietnamese noodle soup, I discovered on a recent reporting trip to Hanoi, can deliver happiness at breakfast, lunch and dinner. At mealtimes, I scanned the streets and headed over to what looked to be the most popular pho stand, took the first free plastic stool and waited for the chef, usually an enterprising woman seated on an identical plastic stool, to assemble my bowl.
When I’m reporting, I like to use all my senses. What does the place look like, sound like, smell like? That way I can give readers a feel for a place they may never have been to.
The soul of pho is the broth, and the genius of the broth is that a bit of meat, not even the best meat, goes a long way. I like the beef version, made with bones, tendon, a bit of brisket, and simmered for three hours or more with charred onions, ginger, the spices of the tropics and the essence of all Vietnamese cooking, fish sauce. Chicken works fine, too, and I’ve even had a vegetarian version, which, I admit, was surprisingly delicious.
I spoke to Vietnamese chefs to learn this.
For me, the lesson of pho is a lesson embodied in many traditional cuisines. Meat can discreetly be the star of the meal. It can be used in small quantities to enrich grains and vegetables.
Each of these five cuisines offers a lesson, and so here I’m explaining clearly why I’m talking about pho: It’s an example of a traditional cuisine that uses meat sparingly, not as the center of attraction. Why is that important? The next paragraph tells you: A report published in a peer-reviewed medical journal — which is my bar for a trustworthy scientific paper — concluded that we eat too much red meat, and that we should eat less of it.
No question, some of us must eat less meat. North Americans eat six times more red meat than they should, according to a recent report published in the medical journal The Lancet. Its authors recommend that we instead fill most of our plates with fruits, nuts, vegetables, legumes and whole grains. They did not suggest that humanity forgo all flesh.
“Forgo all flesh”: I love the sound that words make. I read everything I write out loud, to hear it. But I use alliteration sparingly. Too much of it is too distracting.
(The average Vietnamese eats about a third as much beef as the average American.)
India: Lean in on legumes
Legumes are a universe unto themselves: from fava in the Middle East to flor de mayo in Mexico, cowpeas in Ghana to mung beans in Bangladesh. I’ve eaten them on five continents.
At first, I had a hard time deciding which cuisine I would pick for this section, but then it occurred to me, as I was cooking a pot of dal at home: Why not focus on what I eat a lot of and know really well? Indian food uses all kinds of lentils and beans in all kinds of ways.
Nowhere have I eaten legumes in as many avatars as I have in India. Pigeon peas become breakfast pancakes known as dosa. Chickpea flour, steamed and topped with oil-popped mustard seeds, turns into a fluffy yellow dhokla. Mung beans are repurposed into sweet halwa, swollen with ghee and cardamom.
And then there’s dal, the savory lentil stew without which no Indian meal is complete. The nature of the dal depends entirely on who’s cooking it, where and in which season. It can be made from any of the vast variety of legumes that grow in the region. It can be flavored with green mango or goat, coconut or tomato, even a fish head, which my mother swore would make me smarter. (I refused to eat it.)
Make me your dal and I’ll tell you who you are.
This last sentence (“make me your dal”) is my favorite sentence in this story, because it explains how food can represent us.
Lentils and beans are high in protein and fiber, low in fat. They are good for the planet, too. The Food and Agriculture Organization calls them “climate smart” because they can adapt to rough weather, restore degraded soils and even make cattle feed more digestible.
Again, here’s the why-it-matters paragraph for this section.
Venezuela: Mussel power (and clams and scallops, too)
I like playful headlines
Alejandra Schrader, a chef based in Los Angeles, grew up on shellfish in Venezuela. She remembers a seafood cocktail sold near the beach: steamed plates of mussels and clams, sometimes oysters, soaked with lime and herbs. Levanta muertos, people would call it, roughly, “the resurrector,” because its iron could help revive you after a night of hard drinking.
I could have written about what fish is good to eat, but I learned a surprising thing in reporting this story. I learned that bivalves are a good source of protein and if grown in the right conditions, good for the environment. It came as a big relief, because I love scallops and mussels and clams.
Then, there was her mother’s thrifty paella. The Spanish version — which has mussels and clams but also needs rabbit, a short-grain rice called bomba and a special pan — is often too luxurious for many of us.
But her mom’s version required just going to the beach with a plastic bucket and digging for clams in the sand. At home, her mother cooked a sofrito of onion, garlic and sweet pepper, added some cooking wine, if there was any in the house, and then folded in the clams and a bowl of leftover white rice, which was always in the fridge. No special pans were needed. No fancy ingredients.
“To me it’s very comforting.” Ms. Schrader said. “You add a little cilantro or top it with some avocado, and it’s a really great meal.”
Bivalves like mussels, clams and scallops are a healthy protein, as long as they come from clean waters. That’s important because they filter the waters in which they grow. But, because they are filter feeders, slurping up phytoplankton, they need only a tiny piece of the ecosystem to produce their protein.
“It’s the closest thing you have to a free lunch, from an animal protein perspective,” said Richard Waite, who specializes in agriculture at the World Resources Institute, a research and advocacy group based in Washington.
Kansas: Be kind to the land
I’ve interviewed indigenous people in many countries over the years and I’ve often heard them speak about the land in which food is grown. I wanted to incorporate that idea into this piece, but I didn’t immediately know how. I spoke to several Native American chefs and food scholars. Ultimately, I was able to distill what they told me into a few principles that we could all incorporate.
Every spring, Devon Mihesuah, a professor of indigenous history and culture at the University of Kansas, prepares salads of dandelions from her garden and collects wild onions that grow in the fields. When the frost lifts, she puts gourds and peppers into the ground. She does not spray chemicals to get rid of what others would consider weeds, she says, because bees need them to pollinate.
Those habits are grounded in the culinary tradition of indigenous people. Eating local is part of that tradition, but it’s not everything. Often it means treating food as medicine. Always, it means eating in such a way that doesn’t pollute the place where the food is grown. And not eating all of it.
That’s why Dr. Mihesuah, a member of the Choctaw nation and editor of a forthcoming anthology of essays on indigenous eating, is wary of recommending specific foods. She worries that some could become trendy and then be depleted through overconsumption.
“It’s a real respect for your resources,” Dr. Mihesuah said. “You don’t take all of it. You don’t pull things out by root.”
This was a succinct quote, and to me, it was a really important life lesson.
An example of this principle is the revival of bison, a traditional source of protein for Native people in the Midwest.
Bison have started to make a comeback in the region, replacing cattle, which were brought by European settlers. With them, wild turnips and sage have returned to the land, said Mark Tilsen, co-founder of a snack bar company, called Tanka, on the Pine Ridge Reservation in South Dakota. Many more songbirds are around, and the Lakota people who live there have their traditional source of meat once more. The Tanka Bar is a modern version of a traditional Native snack, made of smoked meat and preserved with tart fruits.
Lebanon: Pass the halloumi, with friends
The other thing I learned in my reporting of this story is that it’s not just about what we eat and how we grow that food. How we eat also matters. So I wanted to use an anecdote to illustrate that idea. I could have chosen so many cuisines for this anecdote. I love the cuisine of the Eastern Mediterranean, so that’s what I chose.
It was a Sunday morning and the kitchen at Beit El Qamar, in the hills above Beirut, was a bright, busy enterprise. Herbs had been picked from the garden out back. Pots were simmering on the stove. Chickpeas were folded into an earthen bowl of yogurt and tahini.
By midday, as my family and I sat on the terrace, small plates of many things appeared on the tables all around. There were cold and hot foods, blended and whole, a spectrum of colors from every part of the landscape. There was sheep cheese, grilled or plain, tabbouleh heavy in mint, walnuts puréed with red peppers, dandelions sautéed with onions, and, for dipping, a bowl of olive oil with crushed thyme and sesame.
I like to be specific, because that helps the reader experience what I’m experiencing. These particular foods also have different textures in the mouth. Ideally, I want my readers to taste a bit of what I’m tasting.
It was all there. Grains, fruits, vegetables, nuts and seeds. There was meat, too. But, as in pho, it didn’t dominate. It hid in the heart of a fried kibbe: ground, spiced lamb cocooned in bulgur.
It was a meal meant to be eaten with others, to be passed around and discussed. A meal designed to slow me down, even if just for an afternoon.
I tell you about this meal because it embodies the final and most basic principle of eating well, both for our health and the health of the planet: eating together.
The why-it-matters of this section.
Sharing a meal can be a good way to avoid waste and overconsumption. There’s usually someone in the group who will pop the last piece of cheese into her mouth (my kid), or scrape the last bits of kibbe from the plate (me).
Not least, eating together makes eating more pleasurable.
Brazil is nudging its people in that direction. Its national dietary guidelines offer not just tips on what to eat, but also how to eat.
“Eat regularly and carefully in appropriate environments and, whenever possible, in company,” they suggest. “Plan your time to make food and eating important in your life.”
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/07/learning/annotated-by-the-author-these-five-cuisines-are-easier-on-the-planet.html
2020-02-07 15:35:00Z
CBMidWh0dHBzOi8vd3d3Lm55dGltZXMuY29tLzIwMjAvMDIvMDcvbGVhcm5pbmcvYW5ub3RhdGVkLWJ5LXRoZS1hdXRob3ItdGhlc2UtZml2ZS1jdWlzaW5lcy1hcmUtZWFzaWVyLW9uLXRoZS1wbGFuZXQuaHRtbNIBeWh0dHBzOi8vd3d3Lm55dGltZXMuY29tLzIwMjAvMDIvMDcvbGVhcm5pbmcvYW5ub3RhdGVkLWJ5LXRoZS1hdXRob3ItdGhlc2UtZml2ZS1jdWlzaW5lcy1hcmUtZWFzaWVyLW9uLXRoZS1wbGFuZXQuYW1wLmh0bWw
Bagikan Berita Ini
0 Response to "Annotated by the Author: ‘These Five Cuisines Are Easier on the Planet’ - The New York Times"
Post a Comment